What St. Benedict's Monks Left Behind in Old Snowmass

The chapel and cloisters at St. Benedict's are green brick, and the monks built them by hand. They opened in 1958, two years after the first brothers arrived from St. Joseph's Abbey in Spencer, Massachusetts, Aspen Journalism has reported. Thanksgiving falls today, and it is the first in nearly seventy years without a Trappist community in the Capitol Creek Valley. The monastery's final public Mass was celebrated on Jan. 11, 2026.

The monks lived by "ora et labora," Latin for prayer and work, and in Old Snowmass much of the work was ranching. That ranch is the part of their legacy still visible from the road. Aspen Journalism quoted one longtime friend of the community describing it: "the prayer is there, not just only in the chapel buildings, but in the fences and the ranches and the stockyards and the hay that they raised."

A Ranch Learned From the Neighbors

The brothers came to Colorado as monks, not cattlemen. They put the property together from parcels bought from Gordon and Lena LaMoy and the Maurin family, then added the Gobo and Gates ranches. LaMoy taught the newcomers to run cattle. In the early years the brothers kept up about 40 miles of irrigation ditches, watered 600 acres of pasture and 600 acres of hayfields, and fed 343 head of beef cattle, The Aspen Times reported in 2023.

The ranch kept that shape into the monastery's final years, though it was run differently. As of June 2025, much of the agricultural land on the estimated 3,739 acres was leased for cattle grazing, and the property's water rights could irrigate as many as 1,500 acres, according to Aspen Journalism. The hayfields, fence lines and ditches along Capitol Creek Road are the brothers' work, and they stayed in place when the brothers left.

The Prayer That Traveled Farther Than the Monks

The other half of the monastery's legacy left the valley long ago. Father Thomas Keating was a pioneer of Centering Prayer, a form of silent prayer rooted in the Christian tradition, and a founding member of Contemplative Outreach. As of November 2024, that organization served more than 40,000 people in 39 countries, Aspen Journalism reported. Keating also brought leaders of very different faiths to the monastery for a long series of interreligious conferences. Father Joseph Boyle studied under Keating and served as abbot for 33 years. He oversaw the retreat center that opened in 1995 and the infirmary added in 2000. Both men are buried in the monastery cemetery upslope from the chapel, along with Father Theophane Boyd, author of "Tales of the Magic Monastery."

Both practices can still be found close to home. Snowmass Chapel runs a Friday Morning Stillness Centering Prayer session on Zoom at 6 a.m. The interreligious conversations continue as the Charis Snowmass Dialogues, a weeklong, invitation-only gathering Charis has held since 2016 in the spirit of the original series, with meetings in locations around the country.

How the Community Wound Down

The community shrank over many years. St. Benedict's went from 18 members in 2009 to 10 in 2022, the Aspen Daily News reported. Five monks were celebrating Mass there when the sale was announced. Talk about the monastery's future began before Father Boyle died and continued under his successor, Father Charles Albanese. In 2020 a committee of supporters floated other uses for the land, from a center for spiritual reflection to a hub for sustainable agriculture.

In 2022 the leaders of the Trappist order voted to close St. Benedict's. The retreat house and bookstore closed in 2023. At one time the bookstore sold books, icons, candles, Trappist preserves and honey from the monastery's own hives. The whole property went on the market in spring 2024 at $150 million.

Aspen Journalism reported the outcome in December: a $120 million sale to Espen LLC, recorded with the county on Dec. 15, 2025. The paper quoted one of the listing agents as saying the buyer plans to use the property as a home. Pitkin County Commissioner Jeffrey Woodruff, whose District 4 includes Old Snowmass, told the same outlet that "the brothers have been amazing stewards" of the valley.

Father Damian Carr announced the final public Mass for Jan. 11. Afterward, four of the five remaining monks moved to other Trappist houses, three to Spencer and one to Oregon. Brother Raymond stayed on site for the transition to advise the new owner, Aspen Journalism wrote in January. The community began with brothers sent from Spencer, and three of its last members went back there. The same report said the listing agent described the new owner as committed to keeping the property's cattle-ranch character and its wildlife habitat.

The Chapel and St. Mary

The chapel has opened at least once since the sale. In March, St. Mary Catholic Church in Aspen told parishioners that its staff had "met with some representatives of the new ownership," who were "interested in occasionally opening up the property for the celebration of Catholic Mass in the chapel." The newsletter announced a one-time Easter Mass there for April 5, led by St. Mary's pastor, the Rev. Joe Grady, the Aspen Daily News reported. That Easter service was arranged by St. Mary, so the parish newsletter is the most likely place for news of any future Mass in the green-brick chapel.

The hayfields Gordon LaMoy taught the monks to work still line Capitol Creek Road. Our Old Snowmass neighborhood guide covers more of the valley around them, and our post on Old Snowmass's Dark Sky certification covers the night sky above the same fields.

If you live along Capitol Creek or Snowmass Creek and want a neighbor's perspective on how the valley around St. Benedict's is changing, David Baer is glad to talk, quietly and on your schedule. Let's Connect.

Work With David

David has built his reputation on a commitment to always focusing his efforts on the goals and needs of his clients, making buying and selling real estate with him a very personalized experience. Contact him today so he can guide you through the buying and selling process.

Let's Connect

Follow Me on Instagram