The Elk Rutting Outside Your Window Have a History With McLain Flats Road

A bull elk let out a bugle somewhere past the fence line along McLain Flats Road early this week, that long rising note that breaks into a low grunt and carries across the whole plateau in the still morning air. It happens most mornings right now. Colorado's elk go into rut in the back half of September, the annual breeding season that turns bulls loud, restless, and a lot less interested in staying out of sight than they were in August.

The herd responsible for the noise is not passing through. It lives here, grazing the open meadows between Aspen and Woody Creek in numbers longtime observers of the area put at roughly 200 animals, visible most mornings before the day warms up. That's a specific, resident population with a home range that happens to overlap almost exactly with the road residents drive every day. And this particular herd has a paper trail at the county that most people hearing the bugling this week have never seen.

A Herd With a Known Address

McLain Flats sits on a high plateau parallel to Aspen's main road, a stretch of former ranchland turned into large private parcels roughly halfway to Woody Creek. Starwood, Aspen's only gated enclave, sits north of the Flats on similarly elevated ground. The character out here has always leaned toward big sky and open pasture rather than tight lots, which is part of why an elk herd can still hold a range this close to town.

McLain Flats still has more open ground than most of the valley, and land-use decisions on McLain Flats have been discussed publicly for years.

The Red Butte Ranch Approval

The Aspen Daily News reported that Pitkin County commissioners voted 3 to 1 to approve a three-home compound known as Red Butte Ranch on the historic 148-acre Stein Ranch site along McLain Flats Road. The property, owned by former Goldman Sachs vice chairman Bob Hurst, sits across the Roaring Fork River from the Burlingame housing complex. The approved resolution capped the homes at 5,750 square feet above ground and 3,000 below, contingent on the purchase of transferable development rights, after Hurst's attorneys had originally sought permission to build one of the three homes at 7,500 square feet.

The report also noted that Commissioner Michael Owsley was the lone dissenting vote. It quoted him calling the project's effect on elk "huge and unfathomable" and saying, of the ranch he'd known for decades, "This has been a heartbreaker for me."

Pam Moore, a longtime McLain Flats resident, was the only member of the public who spoke that day. She told commissioners she'd watched elk get pushed into worse and worse habitat as more of the Flats gets developed, parcel by parcel, and asked them to deny the application outright.

"Aspen has to stand up and say, 'No,'" Moore said, as reported by the Aspen Daily News.

Two members of the Stein family, whose ranch this had been, also wrote in asking commissioners to reject the new homes.

The board weighed those concerns against the applicant's case and approved the project with the conditions described above.

Approval Conditions and Transferable Development Rights

The homes that got built are smaller than what was originally proposed. Transferable development rights don't erase density, they relocate it. The building capacity that gets stripped from one parcel to make it more conservation-friendly generally gets purchased and used somewhere else in the county. The meadow at Stein Ranch got three homes instead of something larger.

The herd's core territory includes the meadows that remain unbuilt. McLain Flats still has more of that open ground than most of the valley. That open ground helps explain why the bugling sounds close.

The Rut Continues Into October

Elk are unusual among big game animals in that they breed in the fall instead of the spring, with a gestation period of roughly 8.5 months. The rut typically runs from mid-September into mid-October, and the loudest, most visible stretch tends to land in the back half of September, which has just ended. Bulls spend these weeks bugling to challenge rivals and attract cows, sometimes locking antlers when neither backs down. By October the herds settle into established groups and the noise tapers off considerably.

How Close Is Too Close

A grazing bull elk can look placid right up until it isn't, and rut season is when that changes fastest. A few practical points worth keeping in mind on McLain Flats Road or the Sunny Side Trail this month:

  • Keep at least 75 feet between yourself and any elk you encounter, roughly the length of two school buses parked end to end.
  • Bulls are actively fighting for and defending cows right now, so an animal that looks calm can close distance quickly if it feels challenged.
  • Dogs off leash are one of the more reliable ways to provoke a defensive charge, worth remembering if you're out walking the trail this week.

Where the Road Ends

Follow McLain Flats Road far enough west and you land in Woody Creek, where the Tavern has anchored the mouth of the valley since 1980. As the Houston Chronicle reported, it was a favorite haunt of Hunter S. Thompson for decades, changed hands in 2020 to Craig and Samantha Cordts-Pearce of Aspen's CP Restaurant Group, and reopened in August 2021 after a four-month renovation that preserved the original wall of Polaroids and memorabilia while adding a saloon addition next door. The elk range covers this same stretch of ground, from the meadows near Stein Ranch to the trees behind the Tavern's parking lot.

The bugling past the fence line this week is coming from a herd that still has open meadow to graze along McLain Flats Road, ground shaped one parcel and one public hearing at a time.

If you're curious how a specific parcel along this road sits relative to conservation easements, transferable development rights, or the county's history of land-use decisions here, that's the kind of local detail David Baer tracks closely. Let's Connect.

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Consult a qualified professional about your situation.

Work With David

David has built his reputation on a commitment to always focusing his efforts on the goals and needs of his clients, making buying and selling real estate with him a very personalized experience. Contact him today so he can guide you through the buying and selling process.

Let's Connect

Follow Me on Instagram